How I Invest with David Weisburd

Thiel's 27-Year Partner on the AI Bubble, the PayPal Mafia and Why Venture Needs the Other 47 States

Key points

Key takeaways from How I Invest with David Weisburd interview with Jack Selby, managing director at Thiel Capital (November 2026):

Venture's liquidity problem. After six months of LP meetings, Selby's blunt distillation: the industry has done a poor job returning capital to investors over the last decade, which is why only eight firms raised roughly $70 billion this year — the capital still positively disposed to private tech is infatuated with shiny late-stage AI deals.

PayPal as talent magnet. One of the first ten PayPal employees, Selby credits Peter Thiel's 'best athlete' hiring approach — not payments experts but the smartest people — and notes the exec team's average age on the IPO roadshow was 26; the eBay sale (around $1.5 billion in 2002) gave a taste of success everyone wanted more of.

27 years with Peter Thiel. Selby has worked with Thiel for 27 of his 28 years knowing him; he calls Thiel's best skill from the PayPal days being a hiring manager, and the constant 'fire drill' of fraud attacks (Max Levchin leading the defence against Russian mobster attempts) forged the team.

90% of capital to three states. Roughly 90% of venture capital goes to California, New York and Massachusetts — and it is becoming more lopsided. Selby argues the Silicon Valley network effect is financial, not human: smart people exist everywhere, but the money is concentrated, creating a circular argument that pushes founders to move.

The next Carvana is not in Palo Alto. Carvana (Ernie Garcia Jr., who raised $65 billion in market cap after failing to raise on Sand Hill Road and bootstrapping with his dad in Arizona) is Selby's proof case: he believes the next one should come from Phoenix, Milwaukee or Cincinnati — AI-enabled businesses don't need to be built in Palo Alto, unlike the next Anthropic.

Copper Sky's counter-bet. His second fund invests in the 47 states at roughly one-tenth of Silicon Valley valuations, sector-agnostic, hunting 'rockstar entrepreneurs' rather than specific industries — the opposite of the access-constrained, expensive sandbox of frontier-lab investing.

AI is a bubble. Selby is explicit that today's AI investment boom is a bubble, even as it lets smaller teams build valuable companies outside traditional tech hubs — he argues entry price matters more than finding the next trillion-dollar company.

Read more: How I Invest with David Weisburd

More top stories