EU weighs mirroring Donald Trump in securing critical minerals
EU lawmakers want Brussels to copy US and Japanese state-backed strategies for securing critical minerals. Last week MEPs voted to create an agency that could take stakes in raw-materials companies 'to safeguard the union's security of supply', build EU stockpiles and monitor supplies. The rapporteur, Dutch social democrat Mohammed Chahim, proposes a Critical Raw Materials Centre funded with €2bn under the next long-term EU budget and modelled on Japan's JOGMEC (Organization for Metals and Energy Security). Chahim himself doubts that is enough: 'If it stays at €2bn, then I don't give the project a high probability of succeeding.' The Commission had planned its own legislative proposal this autumn but scrapped it, so Chahim is pursuing large amendments to the revision of the Critical Raw Materials Act instead. The US benchmark is the Pentagon's $400mn equity investment for 15% of MP Materials, plus a $150mn loan and a 10-year NdPr price floor of $110/kg. Bernd Schäfer (EIT RawMaterials) warns of the US 'becoming a second China for Europe'. This month the EU also selected 46 new strategic projects, adding to the existing 60. Caveats: equity stakes would be allowed only in 'exceptional circumstances' and would need member-state approval; Germany, Spain and others are sceptical; and the centre would need more money from private investors, national governments and the EIB.
Why it matters
Europe is debating a move from grants and offtake talk to state equity in mining and processing companies, the same playbook as the US MP Materials deal and the US fusion stake in the 23 Oct slate. If it passes, an EU agency would become a new co-investor and stockpile buyer for European raw-materials projects and the start-ups around them. But at €2bn, with the Commission's own proposal shelved and key member states sceptical, it is a Parliament position for now, not policy.
Executive takeaways
Vote: MEPs backed an agency able to take equity stakes in raw-materials companies, build EU stockpiles and monitor supply. | • Vehicle: a Critical Raw Materials Centre with €2bn from the next long-term EU budget, modelled on Japan's JOGMEC. | • Rapporteur: Mohammed Chahim (Dutch S&D), who says €2bn gives it a low probability of success. | • Route: the Commission scrapped its planned autumn proposal, so this runs as amendments to the Critical Raw Materials Act revision. | • Limits: stakes only in 'exceptional circumstances', with member-state approval; Germany, Spain and others are sceptical. | • US benchmark: Pentagon $400mn for 15% of MP Materials, plus a $150mn loan and a 10-year $110/kg NdPr price floor. | • Pipeline: 46 new EU strategic projects selected this month, on top of 60 existing. | • Warning: EIT RawMaterials' Bernd Schäfer says the US risks 'becoming a second China for Europe'.
What Financial Times may be missing
The FT gives the Parliament's side but no Commission response (no word from Séjourné or on RESourceEU) and no position from the Council, which must agree. It does not say which minerals or projects the centre would back, how €2bn compares with the capital those projects need, or how stakes would square with EU state-aid rules. The only US comparison is MP Materials; other US government stakes (e.g. Lithium Americas, Trilogy Metals) and how those deals have performed are not covered, so the case that the US model works is assumed rather than shown. 'Next long-term budget' means the money is years away, and the vote's legal weight (committee or plenary, and what happens in trilogue) is not spelled out.