Pinker, Tegmark, Beff Jezos and an xAI co-founder sign 'MisAnthropic Statement' calling Anthropic unsafe on its IPO eve
What happened? On 18 November, the day before Anthropic's shares began trading on Nasdaq, the Center for AI Safety (CAIS) and a coalition of scientists, legal scholars and tech founders published the MisAnthropic Statement. In three sentences it says Anthropic warns that recursively self-improving AI could concentrate power and escape human control "yet races to build it first", uses safety branding to court investors, employees and the public while it "has quietly weakened its safety pledges and lobbied for self-serving regulation", and concludes: "Anthropic is not a safe AI company."
Why it stands out: The signatories rarely agree on AI. Safety advocates such as MIT's Max Tegmark (Future of Life Institute), Nate Soares and Tristan Harris sit next to accelerationists and open-source builders: Extropic founder Guillaume Verdon ("Beff Jezos"), George Hotz, Hugging Face co-founder Thomas Wolf and xAI co-founder Igor Babuschkin. Steven Pinker, Nobel economist Oliver Hart, Turing laureate Judea Pearl, Lawrence Lessig, Laurence Tribe and Fields medallists Peter Scholze, James Maynard and David Mumford also signed. "People in this coalition disagree on almost everything, yet we all recognize the danger of a company that convinces itself its own dominance is the greater good," CAIS executive director Dan Hendrycks said.
The charges: CAIS points to Anthropic's February revision of its Responsible Scaling Policy, which dropped its unilateral commitment to pause, and says the company lobbied to weaken California's SB 1047 and New York's RAISE Act and privately backed federal pre-emption of state AI laws. Hendrycks also said on X that numerous AI safety groups privately agreed but felt unable to sign without risking relationships or funding. That claim is his and has not been independently verified.
Not everyone signed every word: Thomas Wolf wrote on X that he would not have used "reckless" and did not know the statement's name when he signed, but backed its point: a company on track to be "the most powerful company on earth" needs transparency close to that of a sovereign government. He said he would like to be proven wrong and that Anthropic "has the people to do it". Tegmark said he sees Anthropic as "in many ways the AI company doing the most harm".
Anthropic's side: Anthropic had not publicly responded to the statement as of 19 November. It has argued before that one developer pausing while others press ahead could leave the world less safe. In its amended IPO filing of 10 November it said it does not expect Claude to safely build its successors without meaningful human supervision. The filing also flags that the company could be targeted over its safety positions. Some signatories are tied to rivals: Babuschkin co-founded xAI, and Hendrycks has advised xAI on safety.
Why it matters: Anthropic's listing has been sold partly on its safety-first identity. A cross-ideological coalition attacking that brand on the day the stock starts trading moves the debate from AI forums to public-market investors, who now get to price it in.
Sources: The MisAnthropic Statement
Center for AI Safety announcement
The Next Web
Thomas Wolf on X
Max Tegmark on X