NOS resurfaces CPB take on offshore wind: ~€5B net cost, little CO2 gain under ETS
In an NOS Journaal segment from 5 October 2014 that is circulating again, Centraal Planbureau researcher Annemiek Verrips discusses a cost–benefit analysis of large North Sea wind parks commissioned by the Ministry of Economic Affairs.
According to NOS, the study put the net societal cost of the then-planned offshore parks at roughly €5 billion (about €4.8 billion if built closer to the coast), once environmental and health effects were included. Verrips argued that, under the EU Emissions Trading System as it stood then, adding Dutch wind capacity would not cut Europe-wide CO2 because the ETS cap of allowances was fixed — a point she summarised as wind turbines having “no effect on CO2 emissions” within that design. She also said cost reductions assumed in the Energy Agreement looked optimistic and that households could face roughly €120 a year in subsidies for offshore wind alone.
The Kamer-facing study was an MKBA by Decisio and Witteveen+Bos for EZ comparing wind inside vs outside the 12-nautical-mile zone (final report dated 6 March 2014). CPB endorsed the framing that, in the then-current ETS setup, climate benefits were limited — which triggered sharp pushback from then-minister Henk Kamp and from parts of the energy sector, who said the MKBA’s question (nearshore vs further offshore) was being read as a verdict on offshore wind itself.
Critics at the time (including SEO for Natuur & Milieu and several energy consortia) argued the headline “€5 billion damage” overstated or misread the Decisio numbers, underweighted long-term climate and industrial benefits, and treated a broken ETS as a reason to discount wind rather than fix the ETS. Supporters of the CPB line said the waterbed effect and subsidy burden were exactly what a societal CBA should surface before locking in Energy Agreement spending.
NOS YouTube — 5 miljard schade door windmolens · NOS article · Decisio / Witteveen+Bos MKBA PDF · X clip recirculation (Oct 2026)